Ernest Shackleton · chapter 29 of 40

The Making of the Legend

From the book

Legends are not made from nothing. They are made from events that actually occurred, processed through the specific cultural mechanisms that determine which events are told, how often, in what form, and with what emphasis. Shackleton's legend -- the heroic leader, the saviour of twenty-eight men, the man who chose the live donkey over the dead lion -- began forming while he was still alive, accelerated after his death, and has been reforming continuously through each generation's encounter with the Endurance story since 1916. What distinguishes this legend from the purely manufactured kind is that its foundation is real: the events happened, the outcomes were as described, and the qualities attributed to Shackleton in the legendary version are consistent with what the primary sources record. Legends built on real foundations can survive examination in ways that invented ones cannot. Shackleton's has.

Hugh Robert Mill's 1923 biography, the first full-length account and the one Emily authorised, set a tone that was admiring rather than critical and that established the primary narrative: a man of extraordinary courage and leadership who had twice been frustrated in his primary objectives but whose management of the Endurance ordeal was without parallel in the literature of exploration.

More chapters in this book

This is the opening of the chapter. The full chapter, and all 40 chapters, are in Ernest Shackleton.