Menzel’s Jardin des Plantes and the Sommerguth Collection
From the book
Adolph Menzel's In the Jardin des Plantes captures a setting in Paris associated with study, curiosity, and leisure. Its modern history leads instead through Berlin, anti-Jewish persecution, coerced sale, exile, and an unanswered question. The work is a gouache approximately 22 by 35 centimeters, compact enough to fit into the market with few physical obstacles. That portability is part of its mystery. It has been identified in the historical record, yet its public trail ends at the very moment its owners were being stripped of the ability to keep it.
The owners were Alfred and Gertrud Sommerguth. Alfred, born in Magdeburg in 1859, had prospered as a director and co-owner of the tobacco firm Loeser & Wolff. After selling his shares in 1920, he worked in the Prussian Ministry of Interior on city-planning matters. The couple assembled a collection of 106 works, embracing both older masters and more recent art. The Menzel had belonged to the Behrens collection before Alfred bought it from a Berlin dealer in 1936.
Sources cited in the book
- Monuments Men and Women Foundation, “Adolph Menzel — In the ‘Jardin des Plantes,’” WWII Most Wanted Art: https://www.mmwf.org/wwii-most-wanted/menzel/in-the-jardin-des-plantes
Nearby entries in the book
- Bellotto’s Marketplace at Pirna and the Emden Claim
- Queen Victoria’s Paintings at Castle Friedrichshof
- Pissarro’s Banks of the Oise from the Friedmann Home
- Schiele’s Boats Mirrored in the Water
- The Missing Portrait of Rembrandt’s Father
- Czachórski’s Cleopatra and the Poznań Museum
- The Wawel Watercolor Found Through Facebook
- The Lubomirski Madonna Found in Japan
This is a short version of the entry. The full account is in The Encyclopedia of Nazi Lost Treasures, which covers all 160 entries.