The Encyclopedia of Scams, Hoaxes & Deceptions · entry 126 of 250

False Dmitry II

Key facts

Date1607–1610
PlaceRussia
TypeRoyal Imposture & Succession Crisis

From the book

THE SECOND DMITRY

Only a year after False Dmitry I was killed in Moscow, another man appeared claiming to be the same supposedly surviving son of Ivan the Terrible. This second pretender emerged in 1607 during Russia’s Time of Troubles, when dynastic uncertainty, famine, social unrest, and foreign intervention had already weakened confidence in central authority. His personal origins remain uncertain. Contemporary opponents portrayed him as a low-born adventurer, while later accounts proposed several possible identities. What mattered politically was not who he had been before the claim, but whether enough people were prepared to act as though he were Tsarevich Dmitry.

False Dmitry II faced an obvious problem: False Dmitry I had already been killed publicly in 1606. The new claimant therefore needed a second survival story. Supporters argued that the man killed in Moscow had not been the real Dmitry after all, or that the true claimant had escaped once again. In ordinary circumstances such a story might have collapsed immediately.

What the full entry covers

  • A CLAIM THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN IMPOSSIBLE
  • THE TUSHINO COURT
  • MARINA MNISZECH
  • FOREIGN SUPPORT AND WAR
  • DECLINE
  • WHY MARINA’S RECOGNITION MATTERED
  • AFTERMATH

Nearby entries in the book

This is a short version of the entry. The full account is in The Encyclopedia of Scams, Hoaxes & Deceptions, which covers all 250 entries.