The Encyclopedia of Scams, Hoaxes & Deceptions · entry 91 of 250

The Melon Drop Scam

Key facts

Date19th–20th Centuries
PlaceUnited States
TypeStreet Confidence Trick

From the book

THE COLLISION

The melon drop is a classic street confidence trick built around a staged accident. A swindler carries a fragile or supposedly valuable object—traditionally a melon, bottle, package, or piece of glassware—and deliberately collides with the intended victim. The object falls and breaks. The swindler reacts with anger or distress and claims that the item was expensive, rare, medicinal, or intended for an important occasion. The target, believing he caused the accident through carelessness, is pressured to pay compensation immediately. The event feels accidental rather than commercial, so the victim thinks he is repairing harm rather than evaluating a sales pitch.

The object must be fragile enough that destruction seems natural and difficult to inspect afterward. A smashed bottle or broken package cannot easily be valued once it lies on the pavement. The swindler can therefore invent almost any price. If the item is described as imported, antique, medically necessary, or specially ordered, the victim has no quick way to know whether the claim is reasonable.

What the full entry covers

  • THE OBJECT
  • SOCIAL PRESSURE
  • THE NEGOTIATION
  • VARIATIONS
  • WHY IT WORKS
  • SMALL STAKES
  • AFTERMATH

Nearby entries in the book

This is a short version of the entry. The full account is in The Encyclopedia of Scams, Hoaxes & Deceptions, which covers all 250 entries.