The Encyclopedia of Sunken Treasures · entry 247 of 500

What Happened to the Atlantic?

Key facts

Date1852
LocationLake Erie, Canada
Treasure / CargoPassenger valuables, commercial cargo and a documented ship’s safe
StatusPartly recovered / preserved wreck

From the book

Atlantic was a large side-wheel steamer operating between Buffalo and Detroit when it sank in Lake Erie on August 20, 1852. The ship carried hundreds of immigrants and other passengers, together with commercial freight and personal baggage. In the darkness it collided with another vessel and sank rapidly in deep water, producing one of the deadliest passenger disasters on the Great Lakes.

Because many travelers carried cash and savings with them, the wreck quickly acquired a reputation for treasure. A ship’s safe was known to contain money. Historical evidence cited by Great Lakes researchers states that the safe was successfully raised in 1856, four years after the sinking, and contained approximately $5,000 in gold and $31,000 in banknotes.

Sources cited in the book

  • Great Lakes historical reporting on Atlantic and recovery of the ship’s safe
  • Los Angeles Times — 1991 Atlantic salvage controversy and expert response

Related wrecks and discoveries

This is a short version of the entry. The full account is in The Encyclopedia of Sunken Treasures, which covers all 500 entries.