The Encyclopedia of Sunken Treasures · entry 310 of 500

What Happened to the Carnatic?

Key facts

Date1869
LocationSha'ab Abu Nuhas, Red Sea
Treasure / Cargo£40,000 in specie, copper sheeting, cotton, mail and general cargo
StatusSpecie and cargo substantially recovered / intact dive wreck

From the book

Carnatic was a P&O steam-assisted clipper built in London and placed on the Suez-Bombay-China route before the opening of the Suez Canal. On September 12, 1869, she left Suez for Bombay with thirty-four passengers, 176 crew members and a valuable mixed cargo. Among the shipment were copper sheeting, bales of cotton, Royal Mail and approximately £40,000 in specie destined for India.

In the early hours of September 13, the ship struck Sha'ab Abu Nuhas reef near Shadwan Island. Captain Philip Buton Jones initially believed the vessel could remain safely on the reef until another P&O ship arrived. Passengers were kept aboard while efforts were made to lighten the ship by throwing cotton cargo overboard.

The decision proved disastrous. After remaining stranded for many hours, Carnatic broke apart and sank. Thirty-one people died. Survivors reached Shadwan Island in lifeboats and were later rescued by the passing SS Sumatra. A Board of Inquiry found the captain negligent and suspended his master's certificate.

Sources cited in the book

  • The Red Sea Wreck Project — Carnatic
  • P&O historical records — Carnatic
  • Board of Trade inquiry records — loss of Carnatic

Related wrecks and discoveries

This is a short version of the entry. The full account is in The Encyclopedia of Sunken Treasures, which covers all 500 entries.