What Happened to the HMS Eagle?
Key facts
| Date | 1707 |
|---|---|
| Location | Tearing Ledge, Isles of Scilly |
| Treasure / Cargo | Naval artifacts, silver and gold coins, personal objects and artillery |
| Status | Protected archaeological wreck / identification highly probable but not absolute |
From the book
HMS Eagle was a 70-gun third-rate ship of the line lost with Shovell’s fleet in the Scilly disaster of 1707. The ship had been built at Portsmouth in 1679 and rebuilt around the turn of the eighteenth century. It was one of the large fighting ships returning from the Mediterranean when the fleet unknowingly approached the Western Rocks instead of passing safely into the English Channel.
The archaeological site at Tearing Ledge was discovered in 1969 and originally identified as Romney. Subsequent work changed that interpretation. Archaeologists recorded sixty-five iron guns, including pieces too large and too numerous for Romney. Anchor dimensions and a bronze bell dated 1701 also fit Eagle more convincingly.
Personal artifacts strengthened the case. A silver spoon carried initials matching Eagle’s captain, and Historic England now states that archaeologists believe the site to be Eagle, while retaining a formal caveat that Romney or mixed remains cannot be excluded absolutely. This is a good example of identification by cumulative evidence rather than by a single nameplate.
Sources cited in the book
- Historic England — Tearing Ledge Protected Wreck Site
- Historic England — Tearing Ledge Conservation Statement and Management Plan
Related wrecks and discoveries
- HMS Romney — 1707 Scilly Disaster
- HMS Firebrand
- Resolution — Great Storm of 1703
- HMS Mary — Great Storm of 1703
This is a short version of the entry. The full account is in The Encyclopedia of Sunken Treasures, which covers all 500 entries.