What Happened to the SS Samuel Mather?
Key facts
| Date | 1891 |
|---|---|
| Location | Whitefish Bay, Lake Superior |
| Treasure / Cargo | 58,000 bushels of wheat |
| Status | Wreck located / intact wooden bulk freighter |
From the book
SS Samuel Mather was a large wooden steam bulk freighter built in 1887 for the Pickands, Mather interests of Cleveland. The vessel belonged to the transitional era when Great Lakes shipping was moving rapidly from wooden hulls toward steel construction. Its short career makes the wreck particularly useful for understanding that technological change.
On the night of November 22, 1891, Mather was steaming downbound through Whitefish Bay toward Buffalo with an unusually large cargo of wheat—about 58,000 bushels. Thick fog reduced visibility. The steel package freighter Brazil struck Mather on the starboard side near the after hatch, opening a large hole.
Mather sank in roughly twenty-five minutes. All twenty crew members escaped in the boats and were rescued, but they lost their personal possessions. Contemporary accounts valued the ship at approximately $50,000 and placed the combined loss of vessel and wheat cargo at more than $226,000, a substantial commercial disaster for the period.
Sources cited in the book
- Historical Great Lakes shipping records — SS Samuel Mather, 1891
- Published wreck records documenting the 58,000-bushel wheat cargo and Whitefish Bay collision
Related wrecks and discoveries
This is a short version of the entry. The full account is in The Encyclopedia of Sunken Treasures, which covers all 500 entries.