Vasco da Gama · chapter 39 of 40

The Measure of Vasco da Gama

From the book

Measuring Vasco da Gama requires standing between the Cape and the Miri and refusing to look away from either. At the Jerónimos Monastery in Belém, his tomb announces one kind of reckoning: the navigator among monuments, Camões across the nave, the Tagus outside the door from which his fleet departed in 1497. On the Malabar coast, the burning of the pilgrim ship and the hands of fishermen sent in baskets to the Zamorin announce a different reckoning: the armed commercial programme and its civilian costs, the deliberate violence of a man who understood that terror was one of his instruments and who used it accordingly. Both of these reckonings are grounded in the historical record. Neither one alone is adequate. To measure him honestly is to accept that both belong to the same account.

Single verdicts are what commemorative culture prefers, and da Gama's reputation has accumulated more of them than most historical figures. He has been the national hero, the route-opener, the soldier of the cross, the glory of Portugal, the beginning of the modern world. He has also been the pirate, the terrorist, the architect of Indian Ocean coercion, the man who burned pilgrims alive as commercial policy. Each of these verdicts captures something real and distorts the whole by capturing only a part.

More chapters in this book

This is the opening of the chapter. The full chapter, and all 40 chapters, are in Vasco da Gama.