Spain, Portugal, and the Legal Aftermath
From the book
Word of Victoria's arrival at Sanlúcar reached the Spanish court at Valladolid within days of the ship's return, carried by the specific combination of official reports and informal communication that news of significant events always produced in the early modern period. Charles I — who was simultaneously Holy Roman Emperor Charles V — received the news in the context of a court that had been managing an enormous range of political and military commitments since his accession, and whose response to the circumnavigation's completion was shaped by the immediate practical and legal questions that the completion raised as much as by the simple fact of the achievement's magnitude.
Victoria had returned with cloves from the Moluccas, which demonstrated that the western route to the Spice Islands was viable. This demonstration was simultaneously a commercial accomplishment and a legal challenge: it proved that Spain could reach the Moluccas, but it did not resolve the question of whether Spain had the right to trade there under the terms of the Tordesillas treaty, whose specific application to the Moluccas' longitude had never been precisely determined. The cloves in the hold were the evidence that the route worked; they were also the occasion for the diplomatic and legal confrontation with Portugal whose specific terms the circumnavigation had now made unavoidable.
More chapters in this book
This is the opening of the chapter. The full chapter, and all 36 chapters, are in Ferdinand Magellan.