Hernán Cortés · chapter 39 of 40

Hero, Monster, or Founder of New Spain?

From the book

Hernán Cortés is impossible to assess neutrally, and the impossibility is not a defect in the assessor but a property of the subject. He was too consequential, too morally charged, and too thoroughly embedded in the specific catastrophe of the conquest to be approached without the specific weight of what he did pressing on every evaluation of how he did it. Every judgement of Cortés is also a judgement about the conquest — about whether the destruction of the Mexica world was a tragedy, an atrocity, an historical inevitability, a providential design, or some combination of these that no single framework can contain — and every judgement about the conquest is also a judgement about the colonial world that followed it, whose specific character the conquest made possible and whose moral legacy is still being worked through in the societies that inherited it.

More chapters in this book

This is the opening of the chapter. The full chapter, and all 40 chapters, are in Hernán Cortés.