Cook Judged
From the book
Judging Cook is the project that every generation since his death has undertaken, and the judgements have varied — in the direction they take, in the evidence they emphasise, and in the purposes that the judgement is designed to serve — in ways that say as much about the historical moments of the judgement as about the historical individual being judged. The Victorian hero, the colonial agent, the professional navigator, the exhausted commander, the man whose death was contingent, the man whose death was inevitable — all of these are Cook, in the sense that all of them are descriptions that the historical evidence supports to some degree, and none of them is Cook, in the sense that none of them captures the specific complexity of the career and the person without the distortions that the specific purpose of each judgement imposes.
More chapters in this book
- Science, Specimens, and Empire
- Peoples of the Pacific
- Australia, New Zealand, and Colonial Aftermath
- Hawaii and the Memory of Death
- The World After Cook
This is the opening of the chapter. The full chapter, and all 40 chapters, are in James Cook.