The Talmud on Trial
From the book
On 25 June 1240, in the great hall of the French royal palace in Paris, a disputation began that would end two years later with wagons carrying handwritten manuscripts to a public burning. On one side sat Nicholas Donin, a Jewish convert to Christianity who had been excommunicated from the Paris Jewish community fifteen years earlier and had since presented the papacy with a thirty-five-point indictment of the Talmud. On the other sat four prominent French rabbis, including Rabbi Yechiel of Paris, the most celebrated Talmudic scholar in France, who had until recently taught in the same community that Donin had abandoned. The judges were Christian clergy and ecclesiastical lawyers. The king was Louis IX, later Saint Louis, a man of conspicuous piety who had already established his credentials as an enemy of heresy. The outcome was not seriously in doubt.
More chapters in this book
- Books the Church Feared
- The House of Wisdom and the Translation Age
- The Fall of Baghdad and the River of Ink
- Al-Andalus and the Libraries of Córdoba
- The Secret Life of Alchemy Manuscripts
- The Voynich Manuscript and the Unreadable Book
This is the opening of the chapter. The full chapter, and all 40 chapters, are in Forbidden Books.